Tweet
Gov't says voting rights for overseas J'cans not on agenda
Observer Reporter
Saturday, April 22, 2006
DEPUTY Foreign Minister Delano Franklyn says that although the government has been working to strengthen relations with citizens living overseas, the issue of affording voting rights to overseas Jamaicans, while they were residing abroad, is not on the agenda at this time.
"I believe that it will become a very real issue some time in the future, as we can't be seeking to deepen and strengthen the linkages with Jamaicans overseas...and not face this particular issue of whether or not they will be able to exercise their franchise from where they are living," he said.
Senator Franklyn, who was speaking this week with the Jamaica Information Service, said that currently, Jamaicans living overseas can exercise their franchise, and many have come home to Jamaica to vote in national elections.
"For them to be able to do so, however, they need to be registered in Jamaica and they need to come home at the appropriate time to ensure that they are re-verified at the addresses, which they would have filled out on the form here in Jamaica," he said.
He said the issue of having overseas nationals vote in their current countries of residence was raised at the first Diaspora Conference and at the time, the director of elections Danville Walker outlined to the delegates the complex nature of the issue, and the challenges it would pose to the Electoral Office of Jamaica (EOJ).
According to Franklyn, the process of granting voting rights to Jamaicans overseas will have to begin with a comprehensive evaluation of the issue by the EOJ, which would then submit recommendations to the government for consideration.
"It is something which I believe should start with the Electoral Office of Jamaica," he said.
He noted, however, that there were a number of real issues that must be given very serious and deep consideration if Jamaicans living overseas were allowed to vote in elections here.
"The first thing is to be able to identify a Jamaican. It might seem trite, but it is an issue. Who is this Jamaican that you will be according this right to exercise his or her franchise from where he or she lives? Is it a Jamaican with a legitimate Jamaican passport? Is it a Jamaican who has a residence in Jamaica?" said Franklyn.
Other issues to be considered, he said, included voter registration logistics and ascribing votes to the relevant areas, parties and MPs. "If that person is given the right to exercise his/her franchise, where in Jamaica will that vote be registered, and for whom? Which MP would have the right to claim that vote?" he asked.
Consideration, he added, would also have to be given to the possibility that a scenario may present itself, where the party that wins the election does so "by virtue of having the majority of the votes from overseas". This, he Franklyn said, would result in a minority government.
"Just think of the nightmare for policy decisions. Just think of the nightmare that that particular government would be faced with being a minority government on land but a majority government overseas. Would you, in terms of your thinking as a government and Cabinet make decisions (and) principally forge policies relating to Jamaicans living overseas? How would you strike a balance?" Senator Franklyn asked.
Observer Reporter
Saturday, April 22, 2006
DEPUTY Foreign Minister Delano Franklyn says that although the government has been working to strengthen relations with citizens living overseas, the issue of affording voting rights to overseas Jamaicans, while they were residing abroad, is not on the agenda at this time.
"I believe that it will become a very real issue some time in the future, as we can't be seeking to deepen and strengthen the linkages with Jamaicans overseas...and not face this particular issue of whether or not they will be able to exercise their franchise from where they are living," he said.
Senator Franklyn, who was speaking this week with the Jamaica Information Service, said that currently, Jamaicans living overseas can exercise their franchise, and many have come home to Jamaica to vote in national elections.
"For them to be able to do so, however, they need to be registered in Jamaica and they need to come home at the appropriate time to ensure that they are re-verified at the addresses, which they would have filled out on the form here in Jamaica," he said.
He said the issue of having overseas nationals vote in their current countries of residence was raised at the first Diaspora Conference and at the time, the director of elections Danville Walker outlined to the delegates the complex nature of the issue, and the challenges it would pose to the Electoral Office of Jamaica (EOJ).
According to Franklyn, the process of granting voting rights to Jamaicans overseas will have to begin with a comprehensive evaluation of the issue by the EOJ, which would then submit recommendations to the government for consideration.
"It is something which I believe should start with the Electoral Office of Jamaica," he said.
He noted, however, that there were a number of real issues that must be given very serious and deep consideration if Jamaicans living overseas were allowed to vote in elections here.
"The first thing is to be able to identify a Jamaican. It might seem trite, but it is an issue. Who is this Jamaican that you will be according this right to exercise his or her franchise from where he or she lives? Is it a Jamaican with a legitimate Jamaican passport? Is it a Jamaican who has a residence in Jamaica?" said Franklyn.
Other issues to be considered, he said, included voter registration logistics and ascribing votes to the relevant areas, parties and MPs. "If that person is given the right to exercise his/her franchise, where in Jamaica will that vote be registered, and for whom? Which MP would have the right to claim that vote?" he asked.
Consideration, he added, would also have to be given to the possibility that a scenario may present itself, where the party that wins the election does so "by virtue of having the majority of the votes from overseas". This, he Franklyn said, would result in a minority government.
"Just think of the nightmare for policy decisions. Just think of the nightmare that that particular government would be faced with being a minority government on land but a majority government overseas. Would you, in terms of your thinking as a government and Cabinet make decisions (and) principally forge policies relating to Jamaicans living overseas? How would you strike a balance?" Senator Franklyn asked.
Comment